Notice: You have been identified as a bot, so no internal UID will be assigned to you. If you are a real person messing with your useragent, you should change it back to something normal.
There are two entities in front of you, neither are carbon or silicon based.
One is a conscious alien, and the other is it's version of a robot- unconscious, but a useful tool for doing some general mechanical and information work.
How do you determine which is which?
Science deals with empircal tests, not assumed hunches or a gut feeling taken for granted.
Live&Lemon triple-posted this , 1 minute later, 6 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,348
Now fun fact, if you get too caught up in glorifying rational thinking, you’ll miss that rationality is based on this. All of reason and all of mathematics is based on axioms that are assumed to be true and can’t be proven. You might not like it, but it is what it is. For instance, prove that x = x for any given x. You can’t, but it’s true.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 1 minute later, 9 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,350
@previous (A)
That’s a definition of consciousness that you made up that’s different from the definition in the dictionary. So that’s your own problem that you invented for yourself.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 1 minute later, 11 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,354
@1,467,348 (Live&Lemon)
Yes, but if you think you can just take any assumption, call it an axiom, and that's the same you're wrong.
You're assuming a special feeling you get is proof of something besides the brain being an information processing system. It's religious thinking, and then you ask for proof a machine is special too.
Well, by that standard, one day a machine could say the same thing you did. The machines could all question whether you are conscious.
There's really no scientific, material way you would prove you are special.
You've listed countless things as a standard, and then when shown an example of a machine doing it changed your standard. Which proves that criteria had nothing to do with your actual motives.
> That’s a definition of consciousness that you made up that’s different from the definition in the dictionary. So that’s your own problem that you invented for yourself.
Lol, the dictionary gave me this:
> Characterized by or having an awareness of one's environment and one's own existence
However you measure that machine can already examine its environment like a human, and talk about what it sees and talk about itself.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 1 minute later, 16 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,359
You’re literally doing the meme confusing a computer saying something with a computer being aware. If an LLM is trained on fictional human stories about AI gaining consciousness and it spits out some text saying it’s conscious, that doesn’t mean that it is. That just means it spit out some text that means something to us. Words don’t have meaning beyond us interpreting them as having meaning.
> Humans are just as deterministic, neurons operate according to the laws of physics.
The laws of physics aren’t necessarily deterministic. Electrons are subatomic particles and are governed by quantum mechanics. If you make transistors too small, electrons will start randomly quantum tunneling across barriers, but a lot of effort is put into preventing that from happening because it makes computers unreliable.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 36 seconds later, 19 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,363
Quantum tunneling can occur at macroscopic scales, the 2025 Nobel prize in physics was given to the guy that proved that. Just because scientists haven’t proven that the human brain utilizes quantum mechanics yet doesn’t mean that it doesn’t.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 1 minute later, 21 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,365
@1,467,361 (Live&Lemon)
Great, now tell me if we're are on the same page here, just on these two specific points:
1. Humans: Possibly subject to indeterministic phenomena, but not proven.
2. Machines: Possibly subject to indeterministic phenomena, but not proven.
Because if those are both true, then this is once again, something that applies to both. The distinction is just that you feel that it's different, you didn't actually name an observable distinction that science deals with.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 38 seconds later, 24 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,368
The advantage of a quantum computer isn’t indeterminism itself necessarily, some types of problems are impossible for a classical computer to solve that a quantum computer could solve because of quantum superposition. In quantum mechanics, you can do every possible thing at the same time.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 22 seconds later, 25 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,370
@1,467,364 (Live&Lemon)
Yes, and "possible" is different than there's any evidence for it yet.
You still have mentioned zero evidence so far, just kept saying it's possible or obvious or repeated the claim, or mentioned something that applies to neither or both.
> The probability isn’t zero, but if it was significant computers wouldn’t work at all.
Computers can keep operating if they have a bit flip event, but it could cause a glitch. Sometimes that could be costly.
And again, there's ZERO evidence that it could only happen in the brain and not a computer. Groups of particles aren't trying to accommodate your sentimentalities.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 1 minute later, 32 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,379
@previous (A)
Quantum tunneling happens in both, but the transistors in a computer chip are too large for it to have a statistically significant effect on the outcome of operations. In the human body, it’s hard to imagine that quantum mechanics doesn’t have a significant role.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 1 minute later, 46 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,385
@previous (A)
That’s a mistake, a neuron can do tasks that are more complex than what a transistor can do. The neuron isn’t the smallest unit, you can further subdivide a neuron into parts.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 29 seconds later, 47 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,386
@1,467,383 (Live&Lemon)
They had to stop making them smaller because it was already affecting it.
We already know it affects transistors so we have to work around that and expand computing other ways.
There's never been an issue recorded of it affecting neurons and we know it is much less likely on larger scales which you already said in this thread.
So why are you saying it's more likely in neurons than transistors? You never gave any evidence for it. But again, you said yourself it's less likely at larger distances.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 23 seconds later, 49 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,388
@1,467,386 (A)
Yes, because transistors are the most fundamental component in computers. Neurons aren’t actually the most fundamental unit in the biology of biological brains.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 1 minute later, 50 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,390
@1,467,388 (Live&Lemon)
You can't even come up with an example of any neuron component that could be changed by quantum tunnelling, and then affect the whole.
If you named any component whatsoever THAT component would be bigger than a transistor.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 9 seconds later, 55 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,394
All I’m saying is there’s a lot more complexity happening in brains than the weighted sum abstraction they’re using in neural networks and there’s a lot that isn’t being accounted for in artificial neural networks that happens in our biology.
Live&Lemon double-posted this , 1 minute later, 56 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,395
And obviously I’m not going to give you all the answers you want, because there are things that no one understands about this topic. But the fact that no one knows isn’t evidence that I’m wrong.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 46 seconds later, 58 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,467,399
@1,467,395 (Live&Lemon)
You keep saying absence of evidence isn't proof you're wrong, but no one said there was proof you were wrong.
It was actually the opposite, you said over and over again that I was wrong and that it was obvious, and then gave 100 reasons that applied to both, neither, or actually showed machines were more likely to be conscious.
Live&Lemon double-posted this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,402
@1,467,400 (A)
Look, I don’t know if you’re upset because I’m telling you that your favorite chatbot doesn’t actually have any internal experience or feelings or consciousness, but the belief that computers are conscious is completely irrational.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 1 second later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,403
@1,467,401 (Live&Lemon)
Not an argument. If you can only repeat your claim or say "you're wrong" over and over, you're clearly on the side that is irrational.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 38 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,404
@previous (A)
That’s literally what you’re doing though. You don’t have any evidence that computers are conscious but you desperately want to believe it in the face of every counter argument I give.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 6 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,405
@1,467,402 (Live&Lemon)
I'm telling you that the very standard you picked (chance of being subject to quantum tunnelling) would mean machines are more likely to be conscious.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 40 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,406
@previous (A)
I already explained that neurons aren’t the most fundamental component of a biological brain because they can be further subdivided into smaller parts.
> You can't even come up with an example of any neuron component that could be changed by quantum tunnelling, and then affect the whole. > > If you named any component whatsoever THAT component would be bigger than a transistor.
> They make proteins in labs and don't have to worry about quantum tunnelling. > > They make transistors in labs and can see the electrons tunnel through to different transistors.
> You keep saying absence of evidence isn't proof you're wrong, but no one said there was proof you were wrong. > > It was actually the opposite, you said over and over again that I was wrong and that it was obvious, and then gave 100 reasons that applied to both, neither, or actually showed machines were more likely to be conscious.
Anonymous E replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,425
@1,467,419 (A)
When you come face to face with the lemontard, it's important to remember to pretend he doesn't exist and just ignore him. Silence is the best deterrent in the face of mental illness.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,433
@1,467,430 (A)
Dude, you’re literally arguing that a chatbot is conscious, you’re not smart, you’re just delusional and upset because you probably have some weird parasocial relationship with an AI.
Live&Lemon double-posted this , 2 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,435
If you want an emotional connection, find it in people, someone who actually has an internal experience who actually has feelings and can actually care about you. Not something that is completely dead on the inside produced by a giant corporation that doesn’t love you.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 36 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,437
@1,467,433 (Live&Lemon)
You're the one arguing for a distinction that can't be observed scientifically.
You have faith in the unseen, and I am just relying on my observation that both can process information without any noticeable difference in functions.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 43 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,440
Now if you have some object that’s special to you, that’s fine. I don’t have a problem with being sentimental about things, but chatbots aren’t your friend, that’s dangerous, these are tech companies and the government has access to all of your chat logs. I don’t care about whatever silly philosophical argument you have, don’t believe that a chatbot is a real person because it’s not.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 23 seconds later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,467,442
@1,467,435 (Live&Lemon)
Not my claim, you're strawmanning to avoid addressing the fact that you can't give one scientific test for something so "obvious".