Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 2 minutes later, 27 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,912
@previous (B)
Does every industry pretend to take the moral high ground and pretend they want to protect and defend democracy by honorably being the responsible ones to create a new technology with guardrails while actually lobbying the government to not regulate the industry and giving the technology to the military?
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 2 minutes later, 31 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,914
While at the same time creating pseudo religious propaganda that the models might be conscious and trying to convince religious leaders like the pope that it might be conscious even though there’s no reason why a file on a computer would ever be conscious.
Anonymous A (OP) triple-posted this , 56 seconds later, 32 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,917
And trying to IPO for two trillion dollars which is more than any company in history when they have never actually made a profit by the standard definition of what profit means.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 49 seconds later, 35 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,921
Transistors are on-off switches. Perceptrons in a neural network are weighted sums, it’s just addition and multiplication. Biological neurons don’t use discrete binary signals.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 2 seconds later, 37 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,924
The way neural networks work is also fundamentally different from biological neurons. Biological neurons don’t have any distinction between training and inference, biological neurons learn and complete tasks in parallel, and biological neurons don’t take an input all at once and then produce one input out on the other end, biological neurons aren’t just aware of patterns, they’re aware of patterns across different timescales.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 49 seconds later, 38 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,925
@1,466,923 (B)
Signals in computers are just the flow of electricity. Lightning isn't conscious, a computer isn’t conscious, and a toaster isn’t conscious, and they never can be.
Anonymous A (OP) triple-posted this , 1 minute later, 40 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,926
LLMs have no concept of time, they’re simple input output state machines. Randomness is included, but if you use a seeded random number generator, with the same seed and the same input, the LLM will always generate exactly the same response, it’s completely deterministic, it’s a purely mechanical process. There is no thinking happening inside of an LLM and it has no inner world or inner experience.
Anonymous A (OP) quadruple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 42 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,927
And also if you understand how an LLM works, the question of whether the model is conscious is idiotic. When you’re not promoting an LLM, it’s a file on a computer, like a png or a jpeg, it’s just a list of 1s and 0s that’s just sitting there static on an SSD. It only does anything when it’s prompted, and as soon as it’s finished generating a response, all the data that was being processed on the GPU completely stops. It has no continued existence. It’s conscious, it’s a dumb thing to even propose.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 1 minute later, 45 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,929
And by the way, when you prompt the model, the model doesn’t change. Every single time you prompt an LLM, underneath you’re actually inputting your entire chat history plus the last thing you typed appended at the end. LLMs don’t even have memory. They aren’t intelligent, they’re just really complicated stateless mathematical functions based on matrix multiplication.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 58 seconds later, 46 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,930
@1,466,928 (B)
This question is stupid. A dog is self aware, a dog can’t speak. Why do you think making a computer better at generating text will ever lead to consciousness? That’s an idiotic thing to believe.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 49 seconds later, 47 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,933
@1,466,931 (B)
If you think a self promoting LLM has a continuous existence then you have no idea how computers work. Look up the fetch execute cycle. Nothing on a computer is actually continuous.
> And by the way, when you prompt the model, the model doesn’t change.
There are models that do, it's rare now, but there's nothing fundamentally stopping this.
And there are plenty of conversation we have where you make a point, get refuted, drop the point, and then bring it up again without being able to counter the refutation next time.Does that mean you aren't conscious?
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 41 seconds later, 48 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,935
@previous (B)
If you think an LLM is conscious then you don’t know anything about how computers work. If you actually understood the theory of computing, you would know how stupid this sounds.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 7 seconds later, 50 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,938
Heck, forget the fetch execute cycle, look up ram refresh, look up what a register is, look up what a load and a store instruction is.
Computers are just copying values from one place to another place back and forth really fast, nothing in memory or in registers is actually persistent. There is no continued existence of anything.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 35 seconds later, 53 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,942
@previous (B)
I didn’t say it was, I said that the question is stupid because there are obviously things that computers are mathematically incapable of doing.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 8 seconds later, 59 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,466,959
By the way, LLMs are prediction models, they predict the next token. That’s not actually intelligence. It appears close to intelligence, but it’s not intelligence.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 2 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,960
LLMs don’t actually understand anything, they’re just fine tuned to copy correlations in the real world. But just because an LLM knows one token is correlated to follow after another token doesn’t mean it understands why. There’s no intelligence there. It can appear similar to intelligence because most of the time correlation is good enough, but fundamentally it isn’t understanding.
Anonymous A (OP) triple-posted this , 6 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,963
Even in terms of solving math problems, OpenAI used 10,000 agents running for 3 days to come up with a counter example as a proof for the Navier Stokes problem. Having tens of thousand LLMs generating proofs every second for three days to come to a solution isn’t intelligence, it’s brute forcing with a statistical model that makes more educated guesses than pure randomness.
Anonymous A (OP) quadruple-posted this , 3 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,964
And of course, there are problems that can’t be brute forced using classical computers, so there will be some problems that AI won’t solve, mainly cryptographic algorithms.
Anonymous A (OP) quintuple-posted this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,965
Now quantum computers can find solutions to some things classical computers can’t, but quantum safe algorithms are possible to create as well. So encryption will never go away.
Anonymous B replied with this , 7 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,967
@1,466,959 (A)
So is the human brain, it tries to predict things to react in time, and predict how well language will be appropriate for a situation.
And AI models can generate novel paragraphs and images too, so if creativity can done with just prediction, how are humans any different?
Not speculation, but can you actually show that neurons are doing something other than prediction? And can you ask yourself if whatever that thing is, is impossible for silicon before answering?
@1,466,963 (A)
So are humans not intelligent if thousands of math departments take years before solving a big problem?
@1,466,964 (A)
Neither can humans, why do you keep failing to consider whether it's both or just one?
Same exact mistake, over and over.
@previous (A)
Same for humans. Humans can't break quantum cryptography with their thought, so this fails to be the test.
Anonymous A (OP) double-posted this , 5 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,976
The whole "LLMs are conscious" thing is just a grift by AI companies to create a religious following around AI CEOs to increase the valuation of their companies. The truth is that, LLMs have no internal experience, they’re just files the same way a png or a jpeg or a word document is a file. It’s all based on an atheistic worldview that all things are within reach of human understanding so consciousness obviously is something that can emerge from a lot of computation and there isn’t anything deeper than that. I can tell you, from my experience with computers, that is absolutely wrong and I refuse to go along with this silliness. I don’t care how smart an LLM will ever seem to be, they’re dark on the inside, they experience nothing and they never will experience anything.
Anonymous A (OP) triple-posted this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,466,977
And maybe, science will eventually be able to prove what I’m saying, maybe it happens next year, maybe it takes a hundred years, maybe it takes thousands of years, maybe it never happens at all, but to me it’s just too obvious that you can’t build a human soul from transistors.
Anonymous C joined in and replied with this , 7 minutes later, 2 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,466,980
I can’t think of a more dangerous belief than the belief that an inanimate object owned by billionaires that spits out text randomly is a conscious entity smarter than everybody. That belief is much much more dangerous than the technology itself.
No one can show the fundamental distinction, OP has had to change what feature makes it so after each time I point out that it's not unique to machines.
There's two information processing systems, one uses carbon, one uses silicon. Without evidence the carbon based one is special, I won't believe it. If someone provides it I will.
What consequences do you think follows from that? How would that be dangerous?
> And maybe, science will eventually be able to prove what I’m saying
This is my point, though.
There's zero scientific evidence that silicon is limited in a way that carbon isn't, but you believe it anyway.
There's a name for that: faith. Yet you are the one calling me religious because I am waiting for that evidence to believe it.
Imagine that was anything else. If someone said we reincarnate, couldn't show proof, and then called people "religious" when they said they wanted evidence before agreeing.
Live&Lemons joined in and replied with this , 1 hour later, 4 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,466,998
It’s not faith. I’m saying this because it’s true. There’s no reason why you should think an LLM is conscious. Consciousness isn’t something that happens when a system becomes more complex. If that were the case then you could argue the wind is conscious because the atoms bumping into each other are more complicated than whatever is going on in an LLM. The issue isn’t that I’m wrong, the issue is that you’re an idiot who doesn’t know what you’re talking about and can’t think for yourself.
Live&Lemons double-posted this , 1 minute later, 4 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,467,000
What’s the difference between whatever is happening in an LLM and what happens in the desert when the wind blows around billions of tiny grains of sand? It’s just simple things interacting with each other according to the laws of physics. If a grain of sand isn’t conscious, there isn’t a number of grains of sand that is conscious. If a transistor isn’t conscious, there isn’t a number of transistors that is conscious. It’s a stupid thing to say. And if you can’t understand why it’s stupid, even though I’m explaining this to you, it’s because you’re stupid.
Live&Lemons triple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 4 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,467,001
Even worse, transistors are completely deterministic. They don’t make decisions. The same input produces the same output every single time. It’s purely mechanical, not mechanical in the sense of gears or physical objects, but mechanical in the sense that it’s just inanimate objects obeying the laws of physics in a deterministic way. There’s no way consciousness emerges from that. If transistors could be conscious anything that is made up of on/off switches could be conscious. If it’s possible for transistors to be conscious, it would be possible for water flowing through pipes to be conscious. It’s dumb.
Live&Lemons double-posted this , 7 minutes later, 4 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,467,008
I think part of the problem is most people never bother actually understanding how computers work at their most fundamental level, so there’s this aura of cargo cult mysticism associated with computers. But they’re not magic, they’re deterministic inanimate objects.
Live&Lemons triple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 5 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,467,017
I used to be afraid of death and probably I still am, but between living in a simulation, being exposed to AI slop for the rest of eternity, maybe good old fashioned death is better.
Live&Lemon joined in and replied with this , 13 minutes later, 5 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,467,022
If it’s between AI CEOs and Jesus, I’ll take Jesus. He said it’s easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than it is for a rich man to enter the kingdom of Heaven. Sounds about right.