Minichan

Topic: How long do you think modern civilization will last?

Live&Lemon started this discussion #138,580

Do you think we’re just going to experience ever advancing technology and progress, or do you think there’s a chance things could be reset to less advanced stage due to some catastrophic event?

Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU joined in and replied with this , 26 minutes later[^] [v] #1,465,422

I think that at some point there will be some economic crisis which pushes back the standard of living we have become accustomed to, but not as far back as you might think.

Doc !mjoQJhzjwM joined in and replied with this , 11 minutes later, 38 minutes after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,423

I hope it’ll be like 70’s, maybe 80’s.

Anonymous D joined in and replied with this , 6 minutes later, 45 minutes after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,425

India levels would be my guess; pollution pretty high

Anonymous E joined in and replied with this , 52 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,431

I mean we'd have to lose a lot of knowledge and that's much harder these days than back then. You'd have to probably take down the internet, burn a good amount of libraries, kill lots of professors/scientists, and generally destroy relations between most advanced civilizations. That's all possible in some massive world war but probably unlikely. I think the bigger threat is just losing our current quality of life because of robots and AI. So society would still be advanced but you (not of noble birth) wouldn't get those comforts and would probably live in a pod and work 12 hours a day.

Anonymous F joined in and replied with this , 10 minutes later, 1 hour after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,433

@previous (E)

> I mean we'd have to lose a lot of knowledge and that's much harder these days than back then. You'd have to probably take down the internet, burn a good amount of libraries, kill lots of professors/scientists, and generally destroy relations between most advanced civilizations. That's all possible in some massive world war but probably unlikely. I think the bigger threat is just losing our current quality of life because of robots and AI. So society would still be advanced but you (not of noble birth) wouldn't get those comforts and would probably live in a pod and work 12 hours a day.

If you could break enough nodes in the network for power, transportation, and logistics you could set things back. But it would have to be truly calamitous. I don’t believe there’s starting from zero. All the surface metals have been mined so there would be step functions to rekindle advanced civilization.

Anonymous E replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,434

@previous (F)
Maybe for a few months or at best a few years. Countries can get that stuff back up fairly quickly if they really want to

Live&Lemon joined in and replied with this , 47 minutes later, 2 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,444

@1,465,431 (E)
On the first point, all the robots and AI are dependent on one company in Taiwan that makes chips which is dependent on one company in the Netherlands that makes the machines that makes the chips which is dependent on one company in Germany that makes mirrors precise enough to be used in those machines. Even if you had all the knowledge associated with that industry, which most people have borderline no knowledge, if you’re not a trillionaire, you’re not going to have the resources to implement that knowledge. A war in Western Europe or East Asia would set humanity back in terms of technological progress for decades.

Live&Lemon double-posted this , 27 seconds later, 2 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,445

Now on the second point about quality of life, I’m far too depressed by the state of politics and the economy to have a thought about that.

Live&Lemon triple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 2 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,446

@1,465,444 (Live&Lemon)
Also, sorry, I find it annoying when people say this and that without pointing at specifics because it’s vague but I realized I just did that. The companies are TSMC, ASML, and ZEISS.

Live&Lemon quadruple-posted this , 1 minute later, 2 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,448

The thing about the supply "chain" and technological advancement, is the supply chain really is a chain, and the more advanced the tech is, the longer the chain is, but it doesn’t really matter which link of the chain you break, if you break any of them you’ve broken the whole thing.

Anonymous H joined in and replied with this , 11 minutes later, 2 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,455

@previous (Live&Lemon)
raping nigguhs!

Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU replied with this , 29 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,461

@1,465,444 (Live&Lemon)

Robots and AI is a red herring. It will happen because our modern way of handling money relies on constant economic growth which never stops growing ever(which is obviously impossible) and taking on debt. It's a big stack of cards and I don't even know much about it and even I can see that.

Live&Lemon joined in and replied with this , 4 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,462

@previous (Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU)
Tbh, AI doesn’t have to be a bad thing, it’s only bad because the wealthy want to use it to replace us, but there’s no reason why it has to be used to that end specifically. It’s just that’s the only thing they care about. They already have billions / trillions of dollars. The next step is to be billionaires and not have to pay employees. The only issue is, that breaks the flow of money in the economy since the majority of US GDP is consumer spending… if the working class doesn’t have money, there’s no consumer spending which means there’s not much GDP left.

Live&Lemon double-posted this , 3 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,463

Although what I said doesn’t contradict what you said, I think it’s because of what you said. If you can’t have infinite growth on a finite planet, what does someone with infinite greed do in that situation? They can’t sell more stuff because there’s nobody left to sell anything to that’s not already a customer. The only thing left is to cut costs, and their only cost has been their employees basically. So they’re spending trillions to try and get rid of their employees that weren’t costing trillions to begin with, but they’re that desperate to satisfy their greed.

Live&Lemon triple-posted this , 9 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,464

Tbh it’s more likely that AI might be able to automate most jobs, but people just keep working anyway even if on the surface that doesn’t make sense, because if nobody had jobs, the system wouldn’t work, so it will become a paradoxical necessity that everybody does stuff that they technically aren’t needed for.

Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU replied with this , 7 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,465

what you should remember is that capitalism failed in 2008 and it took enormous bailouts to stabilise the situation and even then enormous harm was done. it's only a matter of time until it happens again and you don't need a single robot putting anyone out of work for it

Live&Lemon replied with this , 3 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,466

Of course there’s the UBI idea, that’s not going to happen, but even if it did, you can look up the whole rat utopia experiment. Mammals need struggle, we evolved for it, if you completely take that away everything’s going to shit.

Live&Lemon double-posted this , 1 minute later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,467

@1,465,465 (Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU)
Yeah. To be fair, I was a little kid in 2008 so I wasn’t aware of that whole thing. So I don’t really have first hand experience to compare now vs then, but I’ve asked some people about it that say they see similar signs.

Live&Lemon triple-posted this , 3 minutes later, 3 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,470

Also, I have heard from people who are into history that often when an empire is at its most impressive height when it seems indescribable, ironically, that’s when empires usually collapse.

Sir Carves-A-Lot !nFL78DnUTg joined in and replied with this , 15 minutes later, 4 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,471

Anonymous L joined in and replied with this , 40 minutes later, 4 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,478

@1,465,466 (Live&Lemon)

> Of course there’s the UBI idea, that’s not going to happen, but even if it did, you can look up the whole rat utopia experiment. Mammals need struggle, we evolved for it, if you completely take that away everything’s going to shit.

UBI, what are you a socialist? Real Americans will live in the marginal and decrepit plebelands while the wealthy helicopter above us. Those of us lucky enough to be chosen for daily work will clean the data centers’ gleaming exteriors while the cleaning bots recharge.

It’s all kind of funny because I worked at jobs where the dumbfuck bosses are the kind who would champion AGU, not realizing it would replace them.

Oatmeal Fucker !BYUc1TwJMU replied with this , 7 hours later, 12 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,566

@1,465,467 (Live&Lemon)

Things really fell hard when it happened and if it wasn't for the huge bailouts then the entire financial system would have collapsed, taking everything out with it.

@1,465,470 (Live&Lemon)

It's essentially a complexity issue, civilisations become so complex that the bureaucracy to manage it becomes more expensive than it's worth. And then what you find is that rather than sudden collapses you get managed decline, things become simpler, less lucrative, people experience a lowering of standard of living. But that actually we are the first civilisations after the digital revolution which means that previous data isn't necessarily applicable to us, it's possible that we can sustain maximum global complexity indefinitely in terms of managing it because we don't need one million calculators and reams of paper and a system to share that information because one computer and the internet can deal. But the financial system is the weak point, fiat currency is not based on anything and that's a weakness, the entire system is hacky and it relies on compunding national debt which will never be paid back, and this will force a lower standard of living long before a robotic takeover. So my prediction is a drawn out decline to a mid-20th century standard of living
:

Please familiarise yourself with the rules and markup syntax before posting.