I selectively bought the dip in the “SaaSpocalypse.” Because vibe codes AI scripts weren’t going to magically replace trusted software that handles compliance, purchasing, makes tax assignations, and that comes with service-level agreements and cyber security.
Fucking idiots never consider timelines when they’re caught in hype. Sure, could Anthropic create some market focused plays and disrupt SAP? Yes. Is it a two month proposition? No.
Anonymous B joined in and replied with this , 2 minutes later[^][v]#1,465,350
You are really fixated on proving that AI can't replace programmers.
It doesn't need to replace all of them btw, even if there are still full time human engineers maintaining enterprise software, there will be a lot of grunt code monkey jobs that get automated and then those people will apply for new jobs which drives down swe salaries.
How much debt are you taking on for the CS degree?
> You are really fixated on proving that AI can't replace programmers. > > It doesn't need to replace all of them btw, even if there are still full time human engineers maintaining enterprise software, there will be a lot of grunt code monkey jobs that get automated and then those people will apply for new jobs which drives down swe salaries. > > How much debt are you taking on for the CS degree?
You must mistake me with someone else. I do believe AI can, and that some products will contour to usurp that software. I’m saying you’re not displacing Crowdstrike and SAP tomorrow. Tons of shitty databases with a mediocre “AI-powered” UI will disappear, but not all SaaS overnight.
Live&Lemon joined in and replied with this , 8 hours later, 9 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,476
@previous (C)
Idk why, but for some reason some people have a chip on their shoulder against people that study anything that requires intelligence, so they like to talk shit about "programmers" because of some IQ inferiority complex they have. The truth is that we live in a world where software is necessary. Every company needs software. Even if AI writes the code, somebody still has to use AI to engineer that software, which is why there are still people who studied computer science who work as software engineers who still have jobs.
Live&Lemon double-posted this , 1 minute later, 9 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,477
The issue is that usually junior software engineers aren’t trusted with system level design decisions, because they’re inexperienced, so companies have been hiring fewer junior software engineers, which has inspired a lot of doomerism on the internet from college kids who find it hard to get an internship. But there are some companies that have started to realize that if they don’t train junior software engineers, they’re going to run out of senior software engineers.
> The issue is that usually junior software engineers aren’t trusted with system level design decisions, because they’re inexperienced, so companies have been hiring fewer junior software engineers, which has inspired a lot of doomerism on the internet from college kids who find it hard to get an internship. But there are some companies that have started to realize that if they don’t train junior software engineers, they’re going to run out of senior software engineers.
Short sighted bean counters. I don’t get anyone who shits on their programmers. I remember, probably when you were a child, when data was all on site and the “server room guy” basically ran smaller companies from his enclave.
Sure, you can buy off the shelf software and the endless licensing but do you really want to let their army charge you to customize it?
Live&Lemon replied with this , 2 minutes later, 9 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,480
This also is completely independent of whether you can sell software as a service. There’s a lot of software most people don’t even know about that organizes internal logistics at companies. If you think about a company, say Walmart for example, somehow they have to coordinate all the truck drivers to get the right amount of goods to to right locations in the most efficient way, and they’re going to have to update that system as the company evolves over time. So there are companies you’d never think of as software companies that higher software engineers. And it is true you can get AI to write the code, but you still need somebody who knows what a database is and how to interact with it without risking an SQL injection or deleting the live database, etc. You need people who are educated enough not to do stupid stuff.
> This also is completely independent of whether you can sell software as a service. There’s a lot of software most people don’t even know about that organizes internal logistics at companies. If you think about a company, say Walmart for example, somehow they have to coordinate all the truck drivers to get the right amount of goods to to right locations in the most efficient way, and they’re going to have to update that system as the company evolves over time. So there are companies you’d never think of as software companies that higher software engineers. And it is true you can get AI to write the code, but you still need somebody who knows what a database is and how to interact with it without risking an SQL injection or deleting the live database, etc. You need people who are educated enough not to do stupid stuff.
I’ve used AI for internal tools for things like real estate. I have a way to correlate sales, availability, vacancies, occupied space, rental rates of different classes of buildings, and different types of real estate (office, industrial) into a set of charts and dashboards. Throw in some public records, lawsuits, mitigation and EPA issues, and travel and demographic data. It’s easy to upload new stuff and it’s a sales driver. It sits well behind the firewall in isolation because I don’t know cybersecurity or compliance. It’s used to plan and sell but it can’t touch the public Internet.
Live&Lemon replied with this , 11 minutes later, 9 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,488
@previous (E)
I think that’s the thing though, even as AI improves and more and more of the work can be done using AI, if you have a multi billion dollar business with millions of customers, and that entire thing hinges upon software, somebody somewhere is going to get paid a lot to make sure that thing keeps working.
Live&Lemon triple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 10 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,490
Sort of like how, for instance, it’s been possible for many years to fly an airplane without a pilot, but airlines still pay pilots even though autopilot exists, and the pilots still get paid well because if the autopilot stops working, even if it’s a one in a thousand chance, the thought of that is scary enough they’re willing to pay somebody to be there just in case.
Live&Lemon quadruple-posted this , 36 minutes later, 10 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,465,496
Tbh the airplane analogy is useful in another way: autopilot, self driving cars, guided missiles, missile defense systems, rocket control systems, AI could write all of that code, but if there are any mistakes, people die. For example the Boeing 737 Max MCAS system was designed to angle the plane down to recover from an engine stall, but they made a mistake that caused the plane to automatically angle itself downward towards the ground resisting the pilot’s controls which ended up killing a lot of people. You can imagine situations with AI where even if AI can write the code, humans will still be needed to evaluate it because if it’s wrong people could die.