Notice: You have been identified as a bot, so no internal UID will be assigned to you. If you are a real person messing with your useragent, you should change it back to something normal.

Minichan

Topic: Revitalizing the U.S Animation & Comic

Doc !mjoQJhzjwM started this discussion #138,447

If it were up to me all that’s needed is remove:

-Anything related to anthropomorphism(specifically animals)

- Adult comedy(toilet, dark, etc)

- Superhero

Those three concepts are the primary reasons for the decline in quality. Remove those things and you’ll have content that would rival studios and publishers like MAPPA and shuiesha.

I would then implement a similar category system regarding age like Japan/Korea in the case of comics:

Action/Adventure/Sport/Martial Arts/Fantasy/Horror
Young Male(13-17)
Adult Male(18-35)

Romance/Slice-of-Life/Mystery/Fantasy/Suspense
Young Female(13-17)

Romance/Crime/BL/GL/Slice of life
Adult Female(18-35)

Crime/Thriller/Action/Suspense/Mystery/Horror
Older Adults-Male/Female (35+)


It’s a tentative idea but I believe this would be beneficial and would help provide quality content through strict guidelines. Plus this should in theory please a good amount of people across the board as long as the following criteria is met:

- No pushing for particular identity to be the default. Meaning no “black stories”, “white stories”, “gay lesbian stories.” Just general stories about people and circumstances, regardless of the creator’s background.


- a balance of stylized and realism which is desired. Stories have to look very cool. Not just interesting or unique but cool. Like something you’d wanna collect as a figure(think gundam and gunpla) no more big mouth, family guy, Rick and morty, Newgrounds, DeviantArt, CalArts, Disney)


-no agenda pertaining to ideals. We have enough arm chair philosophers as it is. Nobody wants to be forced to listening to preachy sermons.

(Edited 43 seconds later.)

Doc !mjoQJhzjwM (OP) double-posted this , 9 minutes later[^] [v] #1,464,172

Ultimately the goal is to have jobs for folks but at the same time do away both “woke left”, “edgy right”. Granted I know this is something that a lot of you would disagree with and that’s ok. However I would the two sides are direct responses to the other.

If we can make content where a white guy can watch a story about a character that just happens to be black/brown but never really bat an eye to that detail because the story is not about a black guy but about some crazy situation that could happen to literally to anybody then great. The same is true if it’s the other way around as well. If the protagonist is white guy and he/she is the hero. They’re not a hero because of their race or some benign nonsense. Its just happens that the story is about them in some fantastical situation.

Throw away the politics, ideologues, etc and you’ll have some solid stories, cool looking and memorable art.

boof joined in and replied with this , 10 hours later, 10 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,464,224

like, what if The Flash had some cerebral palsy

Anonymous D joined in and replied with this , 40 minutes later, 11 hours after the original post[^] [v] #1,464,231

@1,464,172 (Doc !mjoQJhzjwM)
So Studio Titmouse?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTw2-bDQIUs

Anonymous E joined in and replied with this , 13 hours later, 1 day after the original post[^] [v] #1,464,321

@previous (D)
No. Not at all. Thats a commissioned project for a film. Outside of that one project, their works very mediocre and are part of the problem. Also dont like that titmouse has a strange monopoly with the animation industry.

Half of the “talent” are just twitter artists with the same hazbin hotel art style or some variation of loud house.

Anonymous E double-posted this , 1 minute later, 1 day after the original post[^] [v] #1,464,322

@1,464,224 (boof)
I’d watch that as long it was drawn stylish and cool and not have his cerebral palsy be the main focus of the show because then it would defeat the purpose of the points above.

Anonymous F joined in and replied with this , 2 days later, 3 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,126

@1,464,321 (E)
Successful studio does something different to your ideas. Yet you think your way of thinking is correct? Sure.

Anonymous G joined in and replied with this , 6 hours later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,198

you know the appeal of furries isn't just that they're animals right? animal characters are given affordances in design that human characters don't get, especially when you're telling things which are otherwise grounded, literary stories, like in maus, but also when you're telling stories about that animal qualia, in stuff like beastars. they're a potent tool for both the metaphorical and the literal. i think this is more arbitrary and reflects your personal taste more than it presents a meaningful step forward for the industry. which is foolish.

Sir Carves-A-Lot !nFL78DnUTg joined in and replied with this , 3 minutes later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,200

What about Toby Carvery?

Anonymous D replied with this , 8 hours later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,312

@1,465,198 (G)
Cartoon humans are plenty expressive
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8nRa8F_Y89M

Anonymous G replied with this , 6 hours later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,339

@previous (D)
sure, i'm not discounting that, but expression looks like a lot of things. again, beastars is kind of instructive here. does the conceptual tension in a predatory animal taking a protective pose around a prey animal scan if they're human beings? how do you depict a human being as being innately predatory without demonizing traits real human beings have? can you do that to begin with?

Doc !mjoQJhzjwM joined in and replied with this , 1 hour later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,355

@1,465,126 (F)
@1,465,198 (G)

Sure.

Perhaps since it’s coming from some random nobody you’re not keen on my take which is alright, This is not new because it’s going to be challenged. However I’ll say give it time though.

Im sure one of your favorite streamers/influencers will tell you what to consume/think because they’re the most popular or informed on kick or whatever.

They’ll reach the same conclusions ive prescribed above and in a 2 years (maybe even less) we’re gonna have this same exact discussion except you’ll agree.

The western animation and comic industry at its current state is stagnant and quite frankly garbage and uninspired. It’s not even a matter of personal taste or this is “subjective” nor is this arbitrary. There’s a reason why most western audiences gravitate towards to Asian media in general.

Also Beastars is a Japanese production and guess what? It looks cool. The artstyle, the design language all aesthetically pleasing. I didn’t care much for the story but it was arguably better than whatever the U.S/U.K could muster up. It was one of the few furry shows that was done well. Enough to catch my attention. I didn’t think of cringe when I watched it.

Anonymous J joined in and replied with this , 1 hour later, 4 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,366

@previous (Doc !mjoQJhzjwM)
> I didn’t think of cringe when I watched it.

That puts you in a minority position

Anonymous G replied with this , 5 hours later, 5 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,443

@1,465,355 (Doc !mjoQJhzjwM)
i literally work in the comics industry, and i'm not making capeslop, none of my friends or peers are making capeslop. capeslop remains omnipresent as it continues to be a money printer, sure, but it's not like good comics art is dead. read more independent comics, read more webcomics, like. have you sat down and read peanuts? peanuts didn't go anywhere and remains a hallmark work of plain old good comics storytelling. have you read homestuck? homestuck is more readable than ever these days and it blew my 15 year old mind like crack cocaine.

even outside of the classics, i spent a lot at the nib and ink festival this year and came away with some of the most unique and cool comics i've read in my life. you have the power to break these cycles, the good comics are out there.

here's some comics i've been reading recently that are by artists who are doing good work.

- flying saucer video, a slice of life comic about a dying dvd rental store
- the works of beanytuesday, a caustic satirist who you have almost certainly seen drawings from
- nothing doing, a pretty good dilbert
- dumbing of age, the lebron james of drama-centric newspaper strips
- kill 6 billion demons, if you want something that is fucking cool
- combed clap of thunder, my personal favorite from nib and ink this year
- homunculus, one of my favorite indie comics ever actually and one i think about a lot in the fallout from AI

this is to say nothing about the insane boom of manga, which i could continue to recommend idiosyncratic picks for but like, you specified the US industry anyway.

all this to say, maybe your media consumption habits are the problem. if you continue to go to the big slopshops you're gonna get fed like you're a pig at a trough. consider... taking a walk on the wild side...

Anonymous J replied with this , 20 minutes later, 5 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,456

the problem with indie comics is that their full of retards that desperately need an overseer to stay on topic. @previous (G)

Anonymous G replied with this , 2 hours later, 5 days after the original post[^] [v] #1,465,491

@previous (J)
my man has never been in a conversation before
:

Please familiarise yourself with the rules and markup syntax before posting.