Notice: You have been identified as a bot, so no internal UID will be assigned to you. If you are a real person messing with your useragent, you should change it back to something normal.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 1 minute later, 40 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,462,779
Idk, I mean, if it was something somebody put actual effort into, it would be interesting, but the way they’re marketing it as just a free clone of something else, idk what I think about that in terms of legality.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 4 minutes later, 45 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,462,780
I think open source projects are cool, I use open source software all the time, but it’s software that people actually put effort into, and they’re not just clones of things that already exist. I guess I don’t see what the point is exactly, since nothing was really invented.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this , 33 seconds later, 46 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,462,781
@1,462,779 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
Ok I got it wrong. They did not "steal" the code. They apparently reverse engineered it. It's a clone, but it's free and open source. Instead of paying Adobe monthly for life and ending up paying them hordes of money, you can gt 100% exact replica for free.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 2 minutes later, 53 minutes after the original post[^][v]#1,462,784
Like the laziness of it. It’s one thing if they actually wanted to build an open sourced image editor or whatever from scratch. If they did that and they were actually writing the code and it was really an open sourced project, that would be interesting. But it seems more like they just vibe coded a clone of a product that already exists and are trying to profit off of it by selling it, yet still pretending they’re doing something honorable, which rubs me the wrong way.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,462,786
Also ideologically, I do like open source software, but this is paying a tech company Anthropic that generates code using LLMs trained on code humans wrote for open source projects in order to sell a repackaged subscription to pay for AI models at other tech companies. Like I get that they’re doing it because people don’t like Adobe, but it seems kinda short sighted because the business model of this inherently relies on tech giants, and I could easily imagine Anthropic or Google doing this to projects made by independent developers since they’re the ones that have all the data and the resources to train the LLMs in the first place. So I’m not convinced that this is actually beneficial to "the little guy" in the long run.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,462,789
Like, I just see a flaw in the logic here. I read some of the things people were writing about this on forums, what they’re thinking is "screw adobe" but the people that made this app didn’t create the tools they used to build the app, Anthropic did. If you create free versions of software by paying tech giants to use the AI models they trained on open sourced projects, that doesn’t actually hurt tech giants, that just makes it harder for anyone else to compete with them.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 1 minute later, 1 hour after the original post[^][v]#1,462,791
Although, it is an interesting problem though in society, that we have multi trillion dollar tech giants that are basically monopolies or near monopolies. I think that’s probably bad for innovation. Idk what the solution is though.
> Ok I got it wrong. They did not "steal" the code. They apparently reverse engineered it. It's a clone, but it's free and open source. Instead of paying Adobe monthly for life and ending up paying them hordes of money, you can gt 100% exact replica for free.
Is it secure? Will it be updated? Or will some Russian piece of shit inject code to access our systems?
> Although, it is an interesting problem though in society, that we have multi trillion dollar tech giants that are basically monopolies or near monopolies. I think that’s probably bad for innovation. Idk what the solution is though.
The goal of all companies is a market they define and dominate. Stagnation always sets in with monopolies because they rent collect. There’s no incentive to innovate. The AI companies want regulation to keep others out. If you look at Facebook, it stole everything Friendster did and pushed all others out of the market. Congress was too inept to regulate tech until it already has formed into mega companies seated beneath oligarchs. At that point, politicians just take their money or hit them up to do vanity documentaries on their wives.
> Is it secure? Will it be updated? Or will some Russian piece of shit inject code to access our systems?
I think that’s part of the bad taste this left me with. I do honestly believe that open source software is an amazing thing and there are some incredible open source projects: Linux, Chromium, most popular programming languages, etc. But those aren’t vibe coded projects even if the programmers use AI to assist in coding, they’re collaborative projects made by thousands of people working together, and that’s really cool. This is vibe coded slop where the person who made it might not even have read all the source code and they didn’t even have an original idea, they just copied something that already exists.
@previous (F)
I like technology, but I don’t like that it feels like the AI companies want to discourage people from being creative. It’s not like the people using apps like this have safe careers, if anything creative professionals using Adobe products are in a worse position than programmers because those tasks are even easier to automate with generative AI, which makes the whole project seem a bit pointless.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 2 minutes later, 13 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,858
For profit companies actually contribute a lot to open source, especially Google. It’s a bit of a catch 22, if you don’t want to support companies, you have to make open sourced software, but if you make open sourced software, any company can repackage it as closed source. I think that’s probably why both exist and neither side has successfully killed off the other side.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc triple-posted this , 1 minute later, 13 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,859
For example, Android is actually Linux, and Linux is open sourced, but Google makes billions off of Android because they take a percentage of profits from anything sold on the Google Play Store.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc quadruple-posted this , 1 minute later, 13 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,860
I appreciate open sourced software I guess but I also don’t contribute to it, because it feels like a bit of a scam if somebody else is going to profit off of it. Like why would you essentially work for Google but not get paid?
Anonymous H joined in and replied with this , 8 minutes later, 13 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,861
Tbh for most software these days, the vast majority of the code in closed source projects is open source packages downloaded from the internet. Only a very tiny portion of the code is different from one project to another.
Anonymous I joined in and replied with this , 4 hours later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,922
@1,462,784 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
Generally you can do that with open source software as long as you remove trademarks names and logos.
Some companies repackage a linux distro with some tweaks and then sell it.
Software wasn't really a scarce resource to begin with, but we're in a time when you can vibe code a clone for anything, and then vibe code it into a custom setup for exactly your situation.
Anonymous I replied with this , 9 minutes later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,930
@1,462,924 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
I really doubt you have this attitude about most things in your life. Is your table at home handmade by you? Did you knit your own sweater?
Most people don't care, they just want something that works so they can focus on the creative expression they chose. Someone is getting an image editing program so they can work on graphic design, not programming.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 5 minutes later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,932
I was avoiding saying it because I didn’t want to come off as disrespectful, but the idea behind this is kind of stupid in two ways. First off, it’s not really screwing over big tech companies because if you vibe code something you don’t actually have any skills and if you lost access to your Claude subscription you wouldn’t be able to program. So you’re still dependent on a tech company. Then secondly, it’s stupid because the idea itself is lazy. Why would you vibe code an adobe clone when the people who use adobe for their jobs could have those careers automated away using generative AI? It’s redundant on more than one level.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc triple-posted this , 5 minutes later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,935
And the thing is, the biggest problem I have with this whole populist anti effort pro AI slop movement, is that the people pushing it are claiming this gives them more freedom because now people who are too lazy to learn how computers work can produce software that they don’t understand. But these AI models are trained on code written by humans, so if humans stop writing code, the AI models stop improving. And the leading AI companies, Anthropic and OpenAI are unprofitable. But this is creating a situation where if nobody can profit off of software except for OpenAI and Anthropic but OpenAI and Anthropic go out of business due to their financial situations, that would be an industry wide disaster.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc quadruple-posted this , 1 minute later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,936
So it’s like, why would you take a competitive industry, destroy the existing talent base, and replace the current ecosystem with a duopoly led by two companies that lose money? That doesn’t make sense.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc quintuple-posted this , 3 minutes later, 18 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,937
In order for AI to improve, they scale up the models, but to use larger models, you need more compute, you need more GPUs, you need more electricity, but they’re already unprofitable, but they’re in a race so they both need to keep making more powerful models, so where does that end?
Anonymous I replied with this , 2 hours later, 20 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,962
@1,462,931 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
Either for the fun of it, or to get a better representation of an idea. The model will just try to get a good example based on a prompt, it won't be exact.
Anonymous I double-posted this , 6 minutes later, 20 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,964
@1,462,935 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
You're missing the point. AI is here regardless, you can't put the genie back in the bottle.
If it's here anyway, I won't be upset with regular people describing what software they want and then using it. That doesn't hurt me, and Adobe doesn't have a patent on simple photo editing concepts.
Corporations can lay off people either way. Even if that ends up being negative for a lot of people.
Talking about AI as if it's one thing, and we all need to be for or against it is dumb. Too many people do this. You can generate a new phone background on device, but people think using AI at all means data centers will suck up all the electricity and water.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 5 minutes later, 21 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,970
If you look backwards in history, there are actually technologies that were invented and then uninvented and then reinvented. Take plumbing for example. The ancient Romans had developed sewer systems, but when the Roman Empire fell, Europe didn’t have sewers again until the 1800s. Or the Native Americans for example developed copper tools and then switched back to stone tools.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc triple-posted this , 2 minutes later, 21 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,971
For instance, data centers, you don’t really need to build data centers. It’s possible to not build data centers, and there are things that could happen that could cause that. I’m not saying we should stop building data centers, I’m just saying, we do have agency.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc quadruple-posted this , 16 minutes later, 21 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,974
Actually, if I’m being totally honest about what I think, it’s a dark thought. The pace of technical innovation humanity is going at, technology almost certainly will go backwards because I don’t think we’re going to have AI weapons and nuclear bombs lying around for thousands of years and not inevitably kill a large percentage of Earth.
Anonymous I replied with this , 2 minutes later, 21 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,975
@1,462,971 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
You would need everyone to do that, and if just one country decided they were going to continue, that country would become the most powerful.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 1 minute later, 21 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,978
Also if you think about it there are more than 200 countries in the world, so there are more than 200 countries that aren’t the most powerful country, yet they still exist anyway.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 2 minutes later, 22 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,986
And anyway, even if we do lead the AI race which right now we are leading it, does that actually improve life for Americans? What’s the end goal here? Eventually OpenAI Or Anothropic or somebody else wins the AI race, there’s only one tech company, nobody has jobs, and one CEO has all the money? If nobody is employed because AI took everybody’s jobs, nobody will be able to buy anything, so the average person would be poorer even if the GDP is higher because of an elite few.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc triple-posted this , 1 minute later, 22 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,988
And like okay maybe some jobs get automated before others, but their goal isn’t to stop. Sam Altman has floated the idea of UBI or whatever, does anybody actually believe that the United States government will ever give us UBI? Does anybody seriously think that our political system will ever allow for that?
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc quadruple-posted this , 7 minutes later, 22 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,462,994
And capitalism, you can look at what it’s done to the birth rate, people in developed countries aren’t having kids anymore. Is this going to make that better or worse?
Anonymous I replied with this , 38 minutes later, 22 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,463,007
@1,462,986 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
The goal is to have the same tools other countries have.
Do we block internet access to countries with AI so they don't talk or spread to the regulated country?
What about trade? If you trade with a country that can automate while your country doesn't they will undercut everything. Who do you export to when other countries have automated production more?
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc double-posted this , 9 minutes later, 23 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,463,015
The US economy is driven primary by consumer spending not by production. In China a smaller percentage of their GDP comes from consumer spending because they’re actually a production economy. Which ties into my point that if you automate away American’s jobs, consumer spending is the majority of our GDP, so if people can’t buy things, that’s not actually a good thing.
Anonymous I replied with this , 2 minutes later, 23 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,463,016
@1,463,013 (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
It doesn't need to do anything to those three to have a big effect on exports. There are many other industries that could shift a lot if one country gained a technological advantage.
Calling it an LLM still is really far behind. It's like when someone says it can't do math, but there's a precise calculator hooked in. Ignores that it can take in almost any file someone would see in a normal day and give you anything back. Give me an excel sheet for this picture of a chart, turn this pdf handout into an interactive website.
You can chat with it in your own voice and discuss an image because there's an audio model and a vision model built in and connected too.
Every industry employs people in corporate roles too, so every industry will get an advantage if they have the latest technology.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc replied with this , 3 minutes later, 23 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,463,017
@previous (I)
Those are different types of models, an image model, a voice to text model, and an LLM are three different things. When you use a product it can have them connected together, but they’re not the same thing.
Anonymous I replied with this , 3 minutes later, 23 hours after the original post[^][v]#1,463,019
@previous (Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc)
Every image model has an LLM included, but it's all packaged as one file.
And there are some speech models that translate to text, generate a text response, and then turn that text into audio but there's also models that generate the output speech directly as a response to the input speech without adding those steps.
When people talk about AI they aren't just talking about LLMs. Body coordination models are necessary for robots, and people typically assume an AI can see and talk.
> Every image model has an LLM included, but it's all packaged as one file.
Are you sure about that? I can see why a text to image model would need tokenization and vectorization of those tokens, I don’t see why it would necessarily function as an LLM since it doesn’t need to generate text.
> Also ideologically, I do like open source software, but this is paying a tech company Anthropic that generates code using LLMs trained on code humans wrote for open source projects in order to sell a repackaged subscription to pay for AI models at other tech companies. Like I get that they’re doing it because people don’t like Adobe, but it seems kinda short sighted because the business model of this inherently relies on tech giants, and I could easily imagine Anthropic or Google doing this to projects made by independent developers since they’re the ones that have all the data and the resources to train the LLMs in the first place. So I’m not convinced that this is actually beneficial to "the little guy" in the long run.
Mr. Bloody Lemonade !0JqexkOGBc joined in and replied with this , 7 hours later, 4 days after the original post[^][v]#1,463,850
@1,463,319 (Bringbackbeef)
Also I’m slightly worried about gaming. Game development is art, and I’ve never wanted to be a game developer specifically, but I’ve seen some really cool things on the internet from indie game developers. If anyone can just decompile a video game and mash it together into whatever they want, I mean, modding has always existed and a lot of people like modding, I don’t have a problem with that. But if you make it so that you can just instantly rip off any game any game developer spent time and effort on, that reduces the incentive for indie developers to actually create quality games, and only billion dollar companies that can develop super advanced encryption or security methods or either just host the game one the cloud (which sounds like it would suck), will be able to actually protect their IP. And obviously if anyone can create a video game, there will be more games, but it’s the quality vs quantity problem.