Topic: Men can menstruate, give birth, breastfeed, and have vaginas.
Anonymous A started this discussion 2 years ago #111,533 Your thoughts?
B joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,257 Shtick.
Bookshelf joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,259 STFUTteh
Erik !AltRitexT6 joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,262 Sounds like bait.
Anonymous E joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,265 Name one man that has given birth.
Anonymous F joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,267 Anonymous E replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,269 @previous (F)
Again, name one man that has given birth.
Anonymous G joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,270 @1,239,267 (F)
'Man gives Birth!'
It will be the EPIC FAKE of the Century! Moon landing, Biden gets 80 million votes etc.
Green !!bO/s3MBcD joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,272 No. Just no.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,315 wow. bunch of transphobes in here.
Anonymous F replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,324 @previous (A)
The state should seize their assets, relocate their children, and make them undergo reeducation.
Anonymous I joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,326 They cannot. Thanks.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,328 @1,239,324 (F)
And this is why we need progressive politicians, to balance out the nutjobs like you.
Anonymous J joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,335 @1,239,267 (F)
This thread is about a woman. Name one (cis) man who has ever given birth. (Trans) men don’t count since we have accounts of them still be able to birth babies.
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,336 @previous (J)
Transmen are real men.
Anonymous K joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,343 *chestfeed
Anonymous A (OP) replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,344 @previous (K)
*breastfeed
Anonymous F replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,346 @1,239,335 (J)
The link was about biological males getting uterine transplants to give birth.
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,350 @1,239,344 (A)
*chestfeed
> give birth
*anal birth
Anonymous E replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,357 @1,239,346 (F)
But I asked you to name one man that has given birth, and that link didn't provide the info I asked for.
Thanks for playing.
Anonymous F replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,360 @previous (E)
They don't share their names? Men get womb transplants. Men give birth.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,372 @previous (F)
A cis man has never had a womb transplant
Anonymous F replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,382 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
I never even said "cis". Read better, sis.
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,388 @1,239,372 (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Yes, because they would no longer be a cis man if they had one.
Anonymous K double-posted this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,389 @1,239,382 (F)
Kook goes by he/him/sir now.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,398 @1,239,388 (K)
Thats not how it works
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC double-posted this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,399 @1,239,382 (F)
Which trans man has had one?
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,403 @1,239,398 (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
How does it work ?
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,404 @previous (K)
Well a cis man wouldnt suddenly become trans if they had a womb transplant because they might be doing it for science
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,406 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
What's so special about doing it for science?
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,408 @previous (K)
I dont understand your question
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,410 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
what part don't you understand ?
Anonymous E replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,468 @1,239,360 (F)
> They don't share their names?
In other words, you can't name one.
> Men get womb transplants.
Name one man that has had a womb implant.
> Men give birth.
Again, name one man that has given birth.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,471 @1,239,410 (K)
About what you mean by special. Special in regards to what?
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,505 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
In regards to you singling it out
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,508 @previous (K)
What did I single out?
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,514 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Go back to the reply you're trying to understand and re-read it.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,517 @previous (K)
I have
What Im thinking you're asking, is does a cis man getting a womb transplant make him trans. Is that correct?
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,520 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Precisely.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,525 @previous (K)
I dont know why it would make them trans in your eyes, so Im not sure how to answer
I personally dont think a cis man getting a womb transplant would make them a trans woman. And also a man of any kind has never gotten a womb transplant
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,528 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Why don't you start by explaining what makes someone trans in your eyes
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,531 @previous (K)
Why dont you start so I know where you're coming from?
Its hard to explain something to you in a way you would understand if I dont know your viewpoints
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,536 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
I don't have a viewpoint. I am trying to understand your viewpoint so I can make my own. To understand your viewpoint it's probably best for you to... describe your viewpoint.
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,538 @previous (K)
You dont have a viewpoint? Thats really odd
Anonymous M joined in and replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,540 @1,239,536 (K)
show some good faith, then we'll talk
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,541 @1,239,538 (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Is it odd to not have a viewpoint on something I don't understand? I don't even know
what we're discussing. How can anyone have a viewpoint in a situation like this?
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,544 @previous (K)
If you dont know what we're discussing, we probably shouldn't continue as I dont know how to help at this point
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,549 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
You can help by explaining what does and does not make someone trans. A simple one or two sentence explanation will do
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,553 @previous (K)
I think that having gender dysphoria makes someone trans
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,558 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Interesting. What if someone identified with a gender they were not assigned at birth but were not dysphoric about it? Would they be trans? Which gender would they be?
If my favourite colour were red but everyone thought it was blue, but I wasn't upset that people were mistaken about what colour I liked best, would that somehow lessen that red is actually my favourite colour?
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,559 @previous (K)
It would be up to them personally about which gender they are, but I wouldn't consider them to be trans
Your bottom example is not comparable and so I have no comment on it
(Edited 24 seconds later.)
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,561 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
Is this the definition of trans most people use? I've never heard this view before. What term would you use to describe someone like this?
Why have you chosen dysphoria as a defining factor of being trans?
If someone transitions and is no longer dysphoric, do they cease being trans?
> Your bottom example is not comparable and so I have no comment on it
How is it not
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,572 @previous (K)
It is a definition many people use. It may be called being a transmed
Many trans people stop identifying as being trans once they can go stealth
Im not going to try and explain why your weird color preference definition isnt relevant
(Edited 28 seconds later.)
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,587 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
> It is a definition many people use. It may be called being a transmed
Never heard of that.
> Many trans people stop identifying as being trans once they can go stealth
Never heard of that. What would you call such a person once that becomes so?
> Im not going to try and explain why your weird color preference definition isnt relevant
Why not?
Kook !!rcSrAtaAC replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,594 @previous (K)
You havent heard of a great many things. Please do some research and get back to me
Anonymous K replied with this 2 years ago [^] [v] #1,239,614 @previous (Kook !!rcSrAtaAC)
What would you call such a person once that becomes so?
> You havent heard of a great many things. Please do some research and get back to me
Where should I start?
↕